During the second Israeli Congress of Chinese Medicine (ICCM), we had a lecture and seminar with Barbara Kirschbaum.
If there will ever be a need to describe the term “cool chick”, Barbara Kirschbaum would easily be the first candidate that comes to my mind.
As fate wanted it, I suddenly found myself on a lunch date with Barbara.
I already had my lunch and Barbara had a bit of salad, black coffee and a cigarette.
Very quickly I asked her the question that she probably heard a thousand times: how did you come to be an expert on tongue diagnosis? You wake up one morning and decide that this is the way to go?
Of course the answer to that second part is no, and she told me the short version of the story- becoming an expert on tongue diagnosis came from her practice, she checks the pulse too but relays on the veins under the tongue, she has ten of thousands pictures of tongues from her clinic, she thinks the tongue diagnosis is much more accurate than the pulse diagnosis, the way that tongue diagnosis is being taught around the world is wrong, the very little attention the tongue diagnosis receives throughout the world is very wrong, and she stumbled upon Chinese Medicine almost by accident- she was a television engineer, and on one journey near Tibet, a monk told her she should quite simply that she was meant to work in Chinese Medicine.
Barbara is a very pleasant person.
She really doesn’t want to bother you too much, all she really wants is to get to the beach and surf.
I don’t know much about surfing but I do know that Barbara Kirschbaum’s lectures are fascinating. Her ability to talk about tongue diagnosis for hours makes on wonder about the quality of that lecture, but her captivating spirit, her energy and smart observation at CM makes her lectures a real treasure.
One is able to be at a lecture and apply the information the very next day at the clinic.
As one woman on in the congress told me “I just listened to Barbara for 4 hours. If she’d talk another 6 hours, I’d be listening and writing every word. She’s amazing”.
So if you get the chance to attend a lecture or a seminar with Barbara Kirschbaum- grab it with both hands.
You will not be sorry.
Barbara Kirschbaum wrote the Atlas of Chinese Tongue Diagnosis, volumes 1 and 2.
To read Peter Deadman’s review on the books click here.
You can purchase the books at Peter Deadman’s JCM website (click on the above link), or through Amazon by clicking here.
Anne
May 7th, 2008 at 11:19 am
Did she elaborate on what she means by “the way tongue diagnosis is taught around the world is wrong”? Does she mean by other TCM practitioners, or allopathic pracitioners?
Yael
May 7th, 2008 at 12:04 pm
Hello my pretty :),
Most schools I know don’t really say too much about tongue diagnosis. Most of them talk about the pulse and stick to that, giving it more emphesis. A lot more emphesis.
Barbara Kirschbaum showed us with amazing photos how she could diagnose even cancer (!) just from looking at the tongue.
A friend of mine was amazed by her ability to diagnose- she looked at his wife’s tongue for a bit and told her intimate things about her relationship with her mother (!!) and about other aspects of her life. My friend and his wife were amazed by how right on the point she was.
I know that I myself never gave tongue diagnosis too much attention. It seemed silly to me.
I was very very wrong.
Anne
May 11th, 2008 at 6:34 am
Wow, that’s really something. Reminds me of when a friend who does auricular acupuncture could tell that I’d had breast surgery just from looking at my ear!
We spend a fair amount of time on tongues in both my schools, but I doubt it will ever get to the level Kirschbaum enjoys. Does she have any other books besides the 2-volume set?
Not to derail the topic here, but honestly — ears, tongues… one would really have to rethink their position on palm reading as well. If any part of the body is a representation or manifestation of the body as a whole, you could probably get fairly expert at reading anything if you just knew where to draw the connections.
Yael
May 11th, 2008 at 1:35 pm
Anne,
Regarding the books- I think the Atlas of the tongue diagnosis are the only books by B.K. That’s what I know.
Lorne Brown
August 3rd, 2008 at 2:04 pm
I had the pleasure of organizing a 3 day Tongue workshop with Barbara in the Fall of 2006. She really is a “Cool Chik” and the information she gives is priceless. I love her lecture style of using mostly case studies and thousands of westerner Tongue pictures. She is coming back to North America in January 2009 to one day on Menopause and two days on Tongues. It is being held in San Diego California. http://www.prodseminars.com
If you know of other great teachers please let me know. It is great when you can find someone who can transmit their knowledge to you the way Kirschbaum can. She gave some good advice after looking at my tongue and talking with me when I saw her in 2006. One was to lose some weight and exercise (I will be seeing her again in San Diego and I am sure she will notice i am actually a few pounds more) and if you really want to deeply master TCM foundations and excel in clinic then do the following:
1. Take pictures of all your patients tongues AND every three months review the past files and learn from your clinical experience as to what is working and what is not
2. Read Steven Clavey’s Fluid and Physiology text cover to cover. She said if you read this book (do not worry about the title of the book) you will understand TCM at a key level
3. Read her two Tongue atlas books
Not only am I a few pounds heavier but I still have not read the books she suggested… I do own them. wait! I did do one thing she suggested. She though t here needs to be more post graduate TCM education…. good courses. I did continue to develop this with Pro D Seminars (www.prodseminars.com)
Yael
August 4th, 2008 at 11:53 am
Lorne,
Thank you for your wonderful comment.
Oh, I know of many wonderful teachers!!
Do you want the whole list?
I agree with B.K, Clavey’s book is a very important book that doesn’t get enough attention, at least here in Israel. I think I had only one teacher who mentioned it.
Keep up the good work and take care,
Yael